The Athlete Identity Crisis

By Vincent Tenti

Introduction

At 29 years old, Andrew Luck had accomplished his dream of making the NFL, making millions of dollars per year, regarded as one of the best football players in the world, a four time Pro Bowler, millions of people know his name, and he was expected to play for another ten years. Then, suddenly at just 29 years old, he retired. When he left football due to injuries and not being able to get back to top form and therefore losing love for the sport, he said: “a part of my identity died”. (The Score) The amount of time it takes to make it to the professional level is what makes an athlete's identity strong. Andrew Luck is far from the only athlete to have to hang up the cleats. The odds of becoming a professional athlete within some of the most popular sports in North America is extremely low. Athletes that play basketball in high school only have a .03% of going pro and even for athletes who play football in high school, the odds are .08%. (Wolfpups.org) For many athletes, sports becomes much more than simply a hobby or career. Years of training, competition, sacrificing other things, and commitment often leads athletes to develop a strong athletic identity, meaning that they begin to define themselves primarily as someone who does sports. While this isn't inherently a bad thing, it can create big challenges when that athletic career comes to an end. Although only a small percentage of athletes reach the professional level, every athlete, no matter what, will eventually experience some form of having to transition away from playing sports. Whether it's caused by retirement, injury, or just simply not being good enough, leaving sports redefines an athlete and their purpose. This paper will explore how athletes experience identity change after their careers end and why this transition can become so difficult. Particularly, within a context of a modern crisis of meaning, attempting to reforge a purpose can be especially difficult for these athletes. More specifically, this paper talks about how athletic identity is created and handled through the lens of psychology, anthropology, and sociology. The psychological research in this paper will argue the emotional effect of identity loss leads to emotional distress and difficulty adapting to everyday life, anthropological research will argue that athletic identity is shaped through the culture athletes were and are surrounded by, and sociological research will argue that losing the social role of being an athlete can make the transition out of sports difficult, but that education, career planning, and support systems help athletes smoothly transition. All three disciplines will use interviews, participant observation, and survey data, and the psychology discipline will also feature self-observation and personal logs by researchers who lost the ability to run because of an injury. Together these disciplines will show the struggle that athletes go through in transitioning away from their athletic identity. This paper argues that developing multiple identities and preparing for life beyond athletics before an athletic career ends can reduce the identity crisis that athletes experience during the transition out of sports. These recommendations could be emailed to NCAA and USports institutions, so that they can relay the information found to athletes who fall under this topic's demographic. These recommendations will also be relevant to sports psychiatrists to let them know to help out the athletes using career transition focused programs.

Psychology

The first discipline that looks at athletic identity is psychology. Psychology explores how thoughts, emotions, and behaviours influence human experiences. The research looking through the lens of psychology is about how when athletes lose their core athletic identity, they often experience emotional distress, uncertainty, and difficulty adapting to everyday life. Even staying with the world of sports after retirement, for instance by getting into the sports side of coaching, media work, or becoming an agent, still can’t completely remove the pain of this transition away from playing competitive sports. Using qualitative interviews with retired gymnasts and longitudinal interviews with retired elite athletes, the studies consistently show that athletes who strongly identify with their sports in their life have a greater identity loss and emotional distress after retirement or after failing to reach the professional level. This section is primarily based upon the research of three academic articles. Lavallee and Robinson (2007), through qualitative interviews with former gymnasts, illustrate that athletes who strongly identify with their sport often experience identity loss and emotional distress after retirement.Zhang et al. (2025) expand on this, indicating that athletes' social identities change during retirement and that stronger social networks and transition support improve adjustment over time. Finally, Zhao et al. (2025) contribute by showing through survey research that athletes with stronger self-identity and professional identity are better prepared for employment after sport. Together, these articles support my argument that developing multiple identities and preparing psychologically for life beyond athletics can reduce the identity crisis experienced after sport.

The first study by Lavallee and Robinson. (2007) argues that athletes can struggle when their athletic career ends because their identity becomes strongly connected to their sport. For example, a gymnast that took part in the interviews for this article said: "I was just floating… I was very lost." (p. 17) The author's study uses qualitative semi-structured interviews and used interpretive phenomenological analysis to explore the five former female gymnasts' view on the topic focusing on their personal experiences with identity change after retirement and the authors don’t give specific questions for this part of the interviews about their experience. The author shows this from his research, for example: "When they did finally end their careers, three of the five participants in the current study went on to explain how they had felt incredibly lost in a world without gymnastics… The other two remaining participants, who both appeared to by-pass this period of disorientation, reported that they had purposefully engaged in pre-retirement planning from a very early age." (p. 26) The study draws a conclusion that many athletes had difficulty adapting because they had built their entire identity around gymnastics and didn't know what to do outside of that sport. The author explains this by giving reference to what Taylor and Ogilvie (2001) have described as a uni-dimensional self-concept. The authors argue that preparing athletes for this transition can make retiring a lot easier . He did this by referring to Grove et al’s.(1997) findings which stated that the one other remaining participant, who had been encouraged by her parents to have a multidimensional sense of self. After she retired from gymnastics, she stated that she was still a “whole person” and was able to move on quickly. (p. 27). This source supports my argument that athletes who fail to reach the pro level or have finished their sports career may experience an identity crisis because they lose the thing that they have spent years working on. It also supports my recommendation that athletes should work on other hobbies while doing their sport so that they can have a thing they enjoy a lot after sports. The author explores this recommendation by saying parents should explain to their kids that they are not gymnasts, they are people that do gymnastics. (p. 27)

The second study from the lens of psychology was done from Zhang et al. (2025) This source is from the discipline of psychology because it explores how athletes' identities change after retirement and how these changes affect their well-being. This source is good for my project because it explains that athletes often struggle after retirement because they lose the social identity that has defined them for all their life. A retired athlete even said: "The sports centre staff did not provide much help to us after retirement... there were no special staff responsible for retirement support." (p. 17). This quote shows how athletes can feel alone and even abandoned after retiring from sports. The authors used a longitudinal qualitative research which is studying the same group of participants over a one year period. The study was on elite Chinese athletes during their transition into retirement. The participants were interviewed twice over a one-year period, once at the start of their retirement and then once more at the end of the year. The interview data was done using reflexive thematic analysis as inspired by Braun et Clarke (2012, 2019) developing their themes in relationship to Social Identity Model of Identity Change “SIMIC” (p. 1) a theory that emphasizes belonging in the way that identities change over time. The authors validated the chosen themes with the participants. (p. 8) They also had a lengthy coding and re-coding stage where the three researchers looked over the theme concepts.(p. 8) 56% of participants said that the significant change in lifestyle after retirement was their greatest barrier to adapting to new social groups, 60% said that differences between the sporting environment and everyday life made it difficult to fit into new groups. One athlete said: "The lack of exposure to different hobbies and activities due to my athlete lifestyle led to me feeling left out in the new groups." (p. 16) On the other hand, 80% of participants said that some of the skills they developed through sports helped them adapt to new groups and activities over time. (p. 16) The authors give their recommendations on the topic as a whole, which is that organizations should begin transition programs before an athlete retires by helping athletes develop more social identities, stronger social networks, and opportunities outside of sports. The authors put that: "upstream intervention will be more effective than downstream remedial efforts". (p. 21)Athletes need to prepare for the way retirement cuts them off from their social networks (p. 21) In conclusion, this source supports my argument that athletes who fail to reach the professional level or retire from professional sports may experience an identity crisis because so much of their identity has been invested in athletics. The author’s conclusion concords with my recommendation that sports organizations should encourage athletes to build friendships, interests, have an education, and have career opportunities outside of sport before retirement so they can have multiple things to turn to afterwards.

A third study from the lens of psychology was done by Zhao et al (2025) This psychology article explores how an athlete's identity influences their readiness for employment after sport. The study relates to my research because it focuses on athletes who have dedicated so much time into their sports and have to eventually adapt to careers and identities afterwards. The researchers in this article look at the psychological factors that help athletes successfully prepare for life after sport. This study used a survey to come up with their results. The researchers gave questionnaires to sports teams, retired athletes' associations, sports organizations, and athlete social media groups. A total of 160 samples were found valid to be used for their research. (p. 1) The sample included 79 active athletes, 10 athletes preparing to retire, and 71 retired athletes. The participants were also from different levels with 88 participants having competed for more than ten years. (p. 3) The researchers used three different scales of measuring their results. Self-identity was measured using the Self-Identity Scale which had an average of 2.9 in a 1 through 4 point system, professional identity was measured using the Professional Identity Scale which had an average of 3.96 in a 1 through 5 point system, and employment readiness was measured using the Employment Preparation Adequacy Scale which had an average of 3.62 in a 1 through 5 point system. (p. 4) The authors then looked at these numbers and did a correlation analysis. They found that athletes with a stronger self-identity showed good employment readiness (β = 0.42, p < .001). (p. 5) Professional identity also showed good employment readiness (β = 0.25, p < .01). (p. 5) These findings show that athletes who develop a stronger and more balanced identity, the author perceived them to be better prepared to transition into their careers after sports. The authors conclude that services for career transitions should strengthen the athletes psychologically, instead of just giving them the routes to a new career. The authors also note that transferable skills like teamwork and leadership developed through athletics can improve employment readiness and can make the transition into a different career easier. (p. 6) This research supports my recommendation that sports organizations, schools, and support programs should encourage athletes to develop stronger identities before retirement. In all, the study shows that athletes with a stronger self-identity feel and are more prepared for employment and have the ability to adapt to different situations better.

Together, these studies show a pattern that athletes who make their entire identity about sports experience emotional distress when that is taken away from them, whether it's from retirement, injury, or not being good enough to go pro. This was shown when the gymnast said that she felt lost after retirement or when in the study from Zhang et al (2025), the participant said they felt left out. Athletes who develop multiple identities and also who receive support are better prepared for the transition out of sports. In all, from a psychological perspective, athletic identity should be viewed as only one part of a person's identity instead of the entirety of it.

Anthropology

The second discipline to look at athletic identity through is anthropology. Anthropology studies how culture and experiences shape people's behaviours and more importantly their identity. From the lens of anthropology, athletic identity is not just the way a person is psychologically, but something that is built through interactions with other people, for example teammates. Anthropological research examines how athletic identity is shaped through culture, relationships, and involvement in the sporting community. Using an autoethnographic study of injured distance runners, qualitative interviews with retired Paralympic athletes, and NCAA athletes perspectives, these studies show that athletes develop their identities through the people and environments around them. This section is primarily based upon the research of four academic articles. Allen Collinson and Hockey (2007) contribute by showing how injured athletes maintain their identities through their everyday routines, relationships, and connection to sporting culture. Smith et al. (2016) build on this, demonstrating that retired Paralympic athletes reconstruct their identities through activism and continued involvement in their communities. Cota Powell et al. (2024) contribute statistical evidence showing that athletes who find meaning in life outside of sport adapt more successfully to retirement. Finally, Jones et al. (2022) explain how athletes rebuild their identities after retirement by emphasizing the importance of culture, community, and supportive relationships, and how these factors can support an athlete through transition out of their sport. Together, these articles support my argument that athletic identity is shaped through culture and social environments, making supportive communities essential for a successful transition out of sport.

A first study that looks through the lens of anthropology is by Collinson and Hockey. (2007) This source is from the discipline of anthropology because it uses personal experiences to show how an athlete's identity is made and maintained through culture, interaction, and everyday practices. The study helps my project by showing that athletes' identities are often built around their sport, making any interruption to practicing that sport a threat to their sense of self. The authors explain that serious injuries are one of the most emotional and psychologically traumatic things that can happen to an athlete because their identity revolves so much around their sport. (p. 11) Instead of interviewing people outside of themselves, the two researchers studied their own experiences after suffering career ending knee injuries. They collected their data over a two-year period in rehab by writing in diaries and logging conversations between themselves which would be used to compare experiences. The data were analyzed by identifying recurring themes and looking back on both logs to reflect on that theme. They also would interrogate each other to narrow down and make a single precise theme. Instead of measuring responses statistically, the authors showed they maintained their identity and how they organized those findings into three forms of identity work: materialistic identification which is maintaining running clothes, equipment, and spaces to train, associative identification which is remaining connected to other runners, and vocabulary identification which is using stories to talk about their identity as runners. The authors conclude that although serious injury threatened their athletic identities, these forms of identity work helped them their sense of self during what they called the "liminality of injury time.“ For example, they continued wearing their running clothes because those materialistic things became "symbolic bridges to the former state,“ This helped them keep a solid athletic identity while they weren't able to compete. (p. 13) The authors also say that the injury changed their view on themselves and their athletic identity for the better. In all, this source supports my argument that athletes experience an identity crisis when they are unable to continue playing their sport, even if it's just for a bit and not permanent. It also reinforces my recommendation that athletes should develop other identities instead of just sports because relying on sports makes the transition a lot more difficult.

A second study looking through the lens of anthropology is Smith et al. (2016) This article writes about athlete identity through the lens of anthropology by exploring how athletes make their own identities within the culture of sports and how those identities change when they have to finally leave their sport. Instead of focusing on the mental health side of it, the article talks about athletes' actual experiences, cultural values, and the sense of belonging. This article finds its evidence using qualitative study interviews with 15 retired Paralympic athletes from different sports. The researchers used purposive sampling to find people who had experienced retirement after going pro. The method used to make their findings were semi structured interviews about their life stories that lasted about 2 hours long. (p. 3) The researchers asked the following questions, “Can you tell me about your sporting experiences?”, “Can you describe who you are?”, “What does activism mean to you” and “Can you describe any experiences you’ve had of engaging in activism”. (p. 8) They analyzed this data by using thematic narrative analysis. They did this by “indwelling” (p. 10) the data, which means going into the data with stories in mind and then they themed the data, which means “coding stories for manifest and latent meaning” (p. 10). They then reviewed the themes against the entire data set to refine and capture complex patterns. The authors found that most participants continued to identify primarily as athletes after retirement and 7 participants described themselves as disabled athletes instead of just athletes, (p. 4) showing how their culture is shaped by both sport and their disability. The authors also talked about a theme they called "political activist identity" (p. 5) showing that the 7 disabled athletes used their athletic experiences to be able to speak out about disability rights and social change. One participant was observed talking to someone saying that he was a paralympic medal winner and went on to say he worked hard for everything he did. (p. 6) This source helped explain how athletic identity is socially and culturally constructed through athletes’ experiences and their sense of belonging within their sports community. More specifically, it shows that retired paralympic athletes often continued to define themselves through both their athletic and disabled identities, with many of them finding new purpose through advocacy and activism from disabled rights. Overall this article shows that leaving competitive sports does not mean abandoning athletic identity, but redefining it to be able to adapt to communities. This article supports my recommendation that sports institutions and athletes should learn how to properly connect to communities and mentors after retirement so that they find a new purpose even if it's still a little in sports, just finding something that doesn't involve playing the sport like advocating for something about sports like what was shown before.

A third study looking through the lens of anthropology is by Powell et al. (2024) This study examines how athletic identity influences former athletes' adaptation to retirement. The researchers surveyed 104 former NCAA Division I athletes, (p. 1) using a starter questionnaire which asked age, sex, etc…, and three questionnaires: the Athletic Identity Measurement Scale (AIMS), the Satisfaction with Life Scale (SWLS), the Meaning in Life Questionnaire (MLQ). (p. 6) Participants rated statements like this: "Sport is the most important part of my life" (p. 6) and this: "My life has a clear sense of purpose" (p. 7) on the scale between 1 and 7. (p. 6) The authors analyzed the data using statistics like t-tests and correlation analyses to figure out the relationships between athletic identity, the meaning in life, and satisfaction in life. The results showed that male participants showed higher athletic identity scores (M = 36.1, SD = 7.9) (p. 10) than female participants (M = 32.1, SD = 7.8) (p. 10) Also in terms of athletes who were eligible to go pro, it was found that: “Draft eligible athletes had higher AIMS scores (M = 36.1, SD = 7.9) compared to athletes in non-draft eligible sports (M = 32.8, SD = 7.9)” (p. 10) The authors also found that there was a relationship between athletes’ search for the meaning of life and actual satisfaction in life after retirement, meaning athletes who are able to find purpose beyond their athletic careers are more satisfied with the transition out of competitive sports. From an anthropological perspective this source showed that athletic identity is shaped by the culture and lifestyle around sports, meaning that athletes who built their meaning and sense of belonging not solely around that culture were better able to adapt after they retired. This supports my recommendation that athletes should develop hobbies, education and work goals, and identities outside of sports before retirement. From an anthropological perspective, the study shows that athletes who establish meaning outside of athletics are more prepared to adapt to life after competitive sports, while relying only on one identity can make it very hard to transition away from sports.

The fourth study that looks at the topic of athletic identity through an anthropological lens explains the effects of athletic identity loss and was done by Jones et al (2022) This article talks about how athletes reconstruct their identities after retirement by going into how culture, community, and relationships impact an athletes life after sports. It relates to my research because it explains that athletic identity is not only made up from your personal ideals, but it is influenced by the social and cultural environments around the athlete. This study explains the struggle of athletes when trying to reshape their identity. The researchers used the experiences of three authors who talked about their own transition out of sports. Instead of using surveys, the researchers analyzed what the three athletes said by looking at it through a Foucauldian view, which analyzes how people's identities are shaped by expectations from society, institutions, relationships, and not by the individual alone, to find a possible connection for a conclusion. Across the three authors' experiences, the researchers found that they experienced a loss of identity after retirement because their sense of self had been closely connected to their role as athletes. There is no statistical analysis but the authors conclude that the athletes become “docile” (p. 4) when they don't expose themselves to other things apart from sports. The researchers concluded that successful identity reconstruction depended on the cultural and social environments that support the athletes during their transition. They also say that it is basically inevitable to avoid the consequences of not being able to move on because athletes at the highest of levels have to become so immersed in their sport, though the authors don’t say how exactly they arrived at this conclusion. (p. 3) This article supports my recommendation that athletes cannot only make their lives about sports because when that ends they can very easily fall into an identity crisis, athletes have to build relationships around people they care about so that they can support you when your sport ends and help you be able to move on and transition easier.

Together, these anthropological studies show that athletic identity is strongly connected to the culture and communities surrounding sports. Allen Collinson and Hockey (2007) demonstrate that athletes maintain their identities through everyday routines, equipment, and relationships even when injury prevents them from competing. Smith et al. (2016) show that retired paralympic athletes can reconstruct their identities by remaining connected to their sporting community through activism and advocacy. Cota Powell et al. (2024) provide statistical evidence that athletes who develop meaning and purpose outside of sport adapt more successfully to retirement and report greater life satisfaction. Finally, Jones et al. (2022) explain that athletes rebuild their identities more successfully when they are supported by strong cultural and social environments after leaving sport. Although each study examines athletic identity from a different perspective, they all conclude that athletes who build supportive relationships, meaningful communities, and identities other than solely their sport are better prepared to transition out of the competitive sport scene and rebuild their sense of self. These findings support my recommendation that athletes should begin preparing for life beyond sport before their athletic careers end. By working on relationships, interests and hobbies, education, and goals not involved with your sport, athletes can have multiple identities which can ease the transition out of competitive sport.

Sociology

Sociology examines how individuals are influenced by the social groups, institutions, and roles that shape their everyday lives. From a sociological perspective, athletic identity isn't just the athlete's personal thoughts and emotions, it's how sport influences an individual's place within society. Athletes often spend years competing at high levels where coaches, teammates, and organizations provide them with social roles and a strong sense of belonging. When an athlete's career comes to an end, many of them lose not only their competitive role but also the social identity and support systems like relationships that have defined them for much of their lives. Sociological research in all, helps explain why retirement from sport can become a difficult transition and what social factors contribute to successful adjustment. This section is primarily based upon the research of three academic articles. Schmid et al. (2024) which contribute by exploring how athletes' social identities change after retirement and how developing identities outside of sport improves their adjustment. Navel (2011) strengthens this argument by synthesizing previous research showing that athletes who fail to prepare for retirement or who experience involuntary retirement caused by injury for example face greater difficulties adapting to life after sport. Finally, Rist et al. (2025) contribute evidence that athletes who voluntarily retire and have confidence because they know what they want to do after sports already experience an easier transition than athletes who are unexpectedly deselected. Together, these articles support my argument that preparing for retirement, developing meaningful social roles, and building identities past only an athletic one leads to an easier transition into society.

This study by Schmid et al (2024) looks through this topic in the lens of the sociology discipline. This source looks at athlete identity through the lens of sociology by exploring how athletes' social identities change after retirement and how social roles and exclusion influence their transition in everyday society. It is a sociological view because it focuses on how athletes' social roles and connections to society change after retirement, instead of just their emotions. This connects to my research because I am studying athletes who dedicate their lives to reaching the professional level but must eventually adjust to life beyond sport. This source does its research using a statistical analysis in a longitudinal study of 290 elite athletes which looked at them through their active careers into their retirement in a 12 year period. Of those 290 athletes, 32.8% were women and 67.2% were men. 63% of the people played individual sports and 37% played team sports. (p.2) The method that was used to find their results is the use of the AIMS, which is the athletic identity scale by brewer et al (1993) (p. 3) Participants responded to the questions through a 1 to 7 scale. Some questions on the survey asked about the highest level the athlete played till, or how many hours did the athlete invest in training per week. Through their stats they found that athletic identity significantly decreased after retirement (b = -2.36, p < .001). (p.8) They also found that athletes who developed identities outside of sport experienced easier identity transitions, (b = -0.32, p < .001) (p. 8) while athletes who continued working in sports maintained a stronger athletic identity. (b = 0.57, p < .001) (p. 8) The authors say that by how negative or positive a number is for the b value it is how much the person's athletic identity has decreased or increased by whatever scale they have. The p value is just to show how confident that result for the b value is. The authors concluded that athletes who focused almost only on sports often got fewer education and work experience which reduced their opportunities after retirement. Also, that social exclusion was a consequence in which athletes lost the social role that once defined them and now had to establish new ones within society. The authors say that former athletes who maintained their involvement in sports tended to also preserve an “athletic identity," (p. 9) meaning that continued involvement in sport can ease the transition into retirement. This source helped to explain how identity loss and social exclusion affect athletes after retirement. It also supports my recommendation that athletes should receive support in transitioning from sports to develop identities outside of sport before retirement, making the transition into everyday life easier and more successful.

These findings are further supported through the lens of sociology from a french study by Navel and de Tychey (2011), Cet article parle des facteurs qui influencent la qualité de la reconversion des athlètes de haut niveau après la fin de leur carrière. L'auteure a trouver sa conclusion par synthétisent les résultats de plusieurs études sur le sujet d’identiter de les athlètes, notamment d'Alfermann et Stambulova (2007), de Brewer, Van Raalte et Linder (1993), de Grove, Lavallee et Gordon (1997), de Cecic Erpič, Wylleman et Zupančič (2004), et de Lally (2007). Toutes ces études ont aidé l’auteur à identifier les principaux facteurs qui influencent la qualité de la transition après une carrière de sport. L'article montre qu'environ 40% des athlètes ne planifient pas leur retraite sportive, (p. 7) ce qui augmente les difficultés d'adaptation après leur carrière. L’auteur explique également que les retraites involontaires, comme les blessures ou d'être pas selecter dans l'équipe, sont associées à d'anxiété, de tristesse, de baisse de l'estime de soi, et de crise identitaire. (p. 7) L'auteure souligne aussi que une forte identité athlétique est corrélée avec des difficultés d'adaptation à la transition de carrière, (p. 8) puisque les athlètes qui s'identifient presque exclusivement à leur rôle sportif ont plus de difficulté à trouver des autres choses a faire dans leur vie. En conclusion, l'article recommande de préparer la transition en poursuivant des études, en développant des intérêts à l'extérieur du sport et en créant un groupe social hors du milieu sportif. Cette source est pertinente pour mon projet, parce qu’elle soutient ma recommandation selon laquelle les athlètes devraient développer une identité multidimensionnelle et des activités autres que le sport afin de faciliter leur transition après le sport.

The third source that looks at athletic identity through the lens of sociology is by Rist et al (2025) This study investigated how professional Australian Football League (AFL) players adjusted to retirement or deselection from their pro sports team. The researchers had 208 players who had played in 2019-2021 and had been deselected complete an anonymous survey. Participants completed validated scaled questionnaires measuring athletic identity, psychological flourishing, financial confidence, career confidence, social relationships, and the influence of sport on daily life. (p. 2)The researchers asked 41 questions like how many seasons did they play or how the transition from one club to another was. The questions were answered using “scaled questions”. (p. 2) The researchers analyzed the data using correlation analyses and descriptive statistical testing to compare voluntarily retired athletes with athletes who were deselected from their teams. The results found that through table 1 (p. 4) that athletes who retired voluntarily rated their club transition significantly better than athletes who were deselected (Mean Rank = 131.8 vs. 94.4, p < .001, effect size Δ = 0.36) (p. 3). Voluntarily retired athletes also saw greater financial confidence (Mean Rank = 117.8 vs. 99.6, p = .04) (p. 3) and greater confidence in handling unexpected financial emergencies (Mean Rank = 116.4 vs. 100.1, p = .03) (p. 3). This was seen in table 2 (p. 4). Also, the participants showed higher levels of psychological flourishing (Mean Rank = 121.3 vs. 97.6, p = .01) (p. 3) than athletes who were deselected as shown in table 3 (p. 4). This source strongly supports my recommendation that athletes should prepare for life beyond sport by developing other interests, career goals, and identities before their athletic careers end. From a sociological perspective, the study shows that leaving elite sport is not only an individual experience but also a transition between social roles. Athletes who relied less on their athletic identity felt better prepared for careers outside football. The findings also suggest that sports organizations play an important role in helping athletes successfully transition into society after their playing careers conclude.

Together, these sociological studies show that retirement from sport is not simply an individual experience the athlete has to go through but a social transition they have to go through. The studies showed through interviews with swiss athletes that preparation helped 92.5% of them, and that planning for retirement is important but not understand which was shown in the french study that said 40$ of athletes don't prepare for retirement, and in the study by Rist et al (2025) where athletes who choose to retire know what their doing allowing for a smooth transition compared to be deselected. From a sociological perspective, successful career transitions occur when athletes are able to replace the social role of athlete with new and meaningful roles within society rather than relying exclusively on their former athletic identity.

Conclusion

Athletic identity is often developed over many years of dedication, sacrifice, and commitment to sport. While this identity can motivate athletes to achieve success, the research provided in this paper argues that relying almost exclusively on having just an athletic identity can make the transition out of sport extremely difficult. Whether athletes retire after a professional career, suffer a career-ending injury, or fail to reach the professional level, many experience uncertainty, loss of purpose, and challenges in redefining who they are outside of sports. Each of the three social science disciplines explored this issue from a different perspective while arriving at similar conclusions. Psychology explained how a strong athletic identity contributes to emotional distress, identity loss, and difficulty adapting after retirement, while also demonstrating that athletes who prepare for life beyond sport experience healthier transitions. Anthropology showed that athletic identity is shaped not only by the individual but also by the culture, relationships, and communities surrounding sport. As athletes leave these environments, they often lose an important sense of belonging that will have to be replaced through new communities and cultures. Finally, sociology demonstrated that retirement from sport is also a major social transition in which athletes leave behind established roles within society. The sociology research showed that education, career planning and social support improve the athletes' adjustment. When considered together, these three disciplines provide a more complete understanding of athlete identity. Although each discipline approaches the issue differently, they consistently show that athletes who develop multiple identities, have supportive relationships, and prepare for careers and as well as have hobbies and interests beyond athletics are more ready to transition into retirement successfully. Ultimately, the paper suggests that the end of an athletic career should not be viewed as the end of an athlete's identity but instead as the beginning of a new stage or chapter of your life. Sports organizations, coaches, families, and athletes themselves all have important roles in preparing for this transition before retirement occurs.

Recommendations

Based on the findings throughout the paper, I recommend that the NCAA Board encourage colleges and universities to put greater emphasis on the overall student experience instead of only athletic success. By helping athletes become involved in campus activities, career planning, and academics, schools can better prepare them for life after sports. I will communicate these recommendations to the NCAA Board by email, explaining how encouraging a more balanced university experience can help reduce the identity crisis many athletes experience after retirement or after failing to reach the professional level. They implement these recommendations by making athletes have to participate in at least one other club that they find interesting or make the benchmark for the minimum grades needed to play the sport higher. This could all help expand the athletes identities, so that they have hobbies and education to fall back on. I would also recommend this to sport psychiatrists and to help the athletes in making transition programs to better move on after they are done with their sports. Also any athletes that feel like they can’t see a future after sports and only identify as an athlete, I would give them these recommendations in this paper so that they can understand and start to create a life beyond sports. By encouraging athletes to pursue education, develop interests outside of sports, build strong social networks, and recognize that being an athlete is only one part of who they are, the identity crisis that often follows retirement and people that don't make it pro after all the hard work can be reduced by a lot. Preparing for life after sport allows former athletes to carry the valuable skills they developed through competition into new careers, relationships, and opportunities, allowing them to find purpose and success after sports.

References

Allen Collinson, J., & Hockey, J. (2007). “Working out” identity: Distance runners and the management of disrupted identity. Leisure Studies, 26(4), 381–398. [https://doi.org/10.1080/02614360601053384]

Cota Powell, A., Berg-Poppe, P., Pickett, A. C., Ikiugu, M., & Lucas Molitor, W. (2024). The effect of athletic identity and other factors on adaptation to sport retirement. Journal of Intercollegiate Sport, 17(3). [https://doi.org/10.17161/w1t2q575]

Jones, L., Avner, Z., & Denison, J. (2022). “After the dust settles”: Foucauldian narratives of retired athletes’ “re-orientation” to exercise. Frontiers in Sports and Active Living, 4, Article 901308. [https://doi.org/10.3389/fspor.2022.901308]

Lavallee, D., & Robinson, H. K. (2007). In pursuit of an identity: A qualitative exploration of retirement from women's artistic gymnastics. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 8(1), 119–141. [https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psychsport.2006.05.003]

Navel, V. (2011). Les déterminants de la qualité du processus de reconversion sportive : revue de littérature. Bulletin de psychologie, 64(4), 307–316.

Rist, B., Quartuccio, C., Smith, B., & Pearce, A. J. (2025). End on a positive note: An exploration of flourishing, identity, and career confidence in professional Australian footballers transitioning out of football. Science and Medicine in Football, 9(1), 76–82. [https://doi.org/10.1080/24733938.2023.2300448]

Schmid, M. J., Hlasová, H., Ronkainen, N. J., Conzelmann, A., & Schmid, J. (2024). Leaving elite sport, abandoning athletic identity? Development and predictors of athletic identity post-retirement. Journal of Exercise and Sport Research, 54. [https://doi.org/10.1007/s12662-023-00934-2]

Smith, B., Bundon, A., & Best, M. (2016). Disability sport and activist identities: A qualitative study of narratives of activism among elite athletes with impairment. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 26, 139–148. [https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psychsport.2016.07.003]

The Score. (2024, November 13). Daniel Jones signs with Cowboys practice squad. [https://www.thescore.com/nfl/news/3149787]

Wolf Pups. (n.d.). Odds of becoming a professional athlete. [https://www.wolfpups.org/uploads/5/7/9/1/57916507/odds_of_becoming_a_professional_athlete.pdf]

Zhang, Y., Haslam, S. A., Haslam, C., & Steffens, N. K. (2025). A badge, a part of my history and also a root: A longitudinal qualitative exploration of the social identity model of identity change in retired elite athletes. British Journal of Social Psychology, 64(3). [https://doi.org/10.1111/bjso.70005]

Zhao, M., Liu, J., & Lyu, D. (2025). The impact of athletes’ self-identity on employment readiness: the mediating role of professional identity. Frontiers in Psychology, 16, 1729917–1729917. [https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2025.1729917]